Home Family Company The Accident The Injustice The Campaign From Martin

The Accident
Marlie Farm Devastated

On Sunday 3rd December 2006 during preparations for a fireworks display, fire broke out at Marlie Farm as a result of a freak accident. 

A call was promptly made to the Fire Brigade at which point the Winter family and employees of the company closed the road to form a cordon to protect members of the public. When the Fire Brigade arrived family members and employees advised the Brigade to direct their hoses towards an inert storage shed  to prevent the further spread of the fire but it was discovered that the Brigade had arrived with precious little water (around half a tender's worth) along with no knowledge of the nature of the site.  This was in spite of  previous risk assessment visits conducted by the Fire Brigade, the last one taking place in 2003.   This should have alerted them to the fact that hazardous materials were stored on the site and it was also stated during the call to the Fire Brigade that it was a blaze at a Firework Factory.

During the incident the following problems and errors occurred:

The site was licensed by Health and Safety Executive and Trading Standards to hold a considerable amount of fireworks .  The Fire Brigade assist the Trading Standards in issuing licences, therefore the Fire Brigade were well aware of the risks involved in this site.  In 2005 Manufacturer and Storage of Explosives regulations of 2005, of which a copy was issued to the Fire Brigade containing fire fighting guidelines and procedures in the event of fires involving or leading to explosives.  In court the chief fire officer admitted that he had received it but had taken no action other than placing it on his bookshelf.  The information provided in the regulations should have been passed on to firefighters to be used in such an incident, but sadly it was not adhered to.  East Sussex is considered to have the largest concentration of explosive stores in the country so therefore these procedures, including information being available to firefighters via on board computers in their cabs, should have been readily available.

The Fire Brigade ignored their own guidelines of a 600 meter cordon being placed around the site.

Lack of training in terms of how to combat a fire involving fireworks

The Fire Brigade ignored advice from the on-site experts

The Police arrested Nathan as he was trying to evacuate the site due to the increasing risk

Martin drew a site plan highlighting the most high risk areas on site only to be ignored and then to have a policeman spit in his face

Stuart Winter also highlighted to a fire officer the possibility of a container exploding which could cause loss of life only to be told by the firemen that they were the professionals and knew what they were doing

A fireman telephoned his family inviting them to come and attend the "free fireworks display"

Members of the public were in a nearby Inn and they were allowed to approach the site for a closer look and were subsequently injured due to the lack of a cordon that should have been set up by the Emergency Services

Martin asked the Brigade if he in person could open the doors to the storage shed so that they could soak the inert materials to stop the spread of fire, but was refused

The Brigade instead directed water on to the pitched tin roof of the shed at which point they ran out of water after around 30 seconds of spasmodic spraying

The Brigade claimed to know the location of the hydrant but then had to be shown by a member of the public where it was located

This hydrant had been found to be faulty during the Brigade's own inspection during the summer of 2006, but no repairs had been made

An hour after the arrival of the Fire Brigade, a metal container that had been partly loaded that morning to be shipped to Oman exploded causing the death of one retained Fireman and one Fire Support/Media/civilian - there were conflicting accounts by the Fire Brigade during the court case as to the content of this container, in spite of being told by the only experts on the site (the Winters) that the contents posed a serious threat of explosion.
 
  Twenty other people were injured including members of the public who were freely able to approach the site for a better view without being challenged.

Whilst the family deeply and sincerely regret the loss of life and injury suffered during this tragic incident, it is a fact that had the Fire Brigade's own procedures, and the advice given by the experts on the site (family and staff), been followed these tragedies would never have occurred.

Please click onto Page 2 for more information on the accident and its similarities to other incidents.

Previous  Page:  1  2  Next

Free The Winters Camapign Contacts